The Raid on German Flatts

September 17, 1778 at Herkimer, New York

Battle Summary

The Attack on German Flatts was a raid on the frontier settlement of German Flatts, New York (which then also encompassed what is now Herkimer). The attack was made by a mixed force of Loyalists and Iroquois under the overall command of Mohawk leader Joseph Brant, and resulted in the destruction of houses, barns, and crops, and the taking of livestock for the raiders' use. The settlers, warned by the heroic run of Adam Helmer, took refuge in local forts but were too militarily weak to stop the raiders.

Brant's attack was one of a series executed under his command or that of Loyalist and Seneca leaders against communities on what was then the frontier of western New York and northern Pennsylvania. New York authorities responded by ordering an expedition that destroyed Brant's forward operating bases in Iroquois territory.

Facts about the Siege of Boston

• Armies - American Forces was commanded by Col. Peter Bellinger and consisted of uknown number of militia. British Forces was commanded by Chief Joseph Brant and Capt. William Caldwell and consisted of about 450 Indians and Soldiers.
• Casualties - American casualties were estimated to be 3 killed and 719 homeless. British casualties were unknown.
• Outcome - The result of the raid was a British victory. The raid was part of the Northern Theater 1778-82.

Prelude

With the failure of British Lieutenant General John Burgoyne's campaign to the Hudson after the Battles of Saratoga (First and Second), the Revolutionary War in upstate New York became a frontier war. British leaders in the Province of Quebec supported Loyalist and Native American partisan fighters with supplies and armaments. During the winter of 1777–78, Brant and other British-allied Indians developed plans to attack frontier settlements in New York and Pennsylvania.

In February, Brant established a base of operations at Onaquaga (present-day Windsor, New York). He recruited a mix of Iroquois and Loyalists estimated to number between 200-300 by the time he began his campaign in late May. One of his objectives was to acquire provisions for his forces and those of John Butler, who was planning operations in the Susquehanna River valley. His first expedition was a raid on Cobleskill, and he raided other frontier communities throughout the summer.

The western New York frontier ran from Fort Stanwix (present-day Utica) south along the Unadilla River. German Flatts was located about one third of the way east from there to Albany, along the Mohawk River. The Indian towns of Unadilla and Onaquaga were located near the mouth of the Unadilla River, where it empties into the Susquehanna.

When he raided settlements at Springfield and Andrustown (present-day Jordanville) in July, Brant left the survivors with warnings that German Flatts would soon also be attacked. The settlement of German Flatts (now known as Herkimer) was founded in 1723 by Palatine German immigrants. The district was defended by a local militia regiment under the command of Colonel Peter Bellinger. There were two main forts, Fort Dayton and Fort Herkimer, on either side of the Mohawk.

Although Brant had planned on raiding German Flatts sooner than September, the absence of John Butler delayed his plans. Butler had returned to Fort Niagara after his attack on the Wyoming Valley communities in July, sending Capt. William Caldwell to Unaquaga to recruit men for the unit known as Butler's Rangers.

By early September, it was clear that Butler was not returning to the area, so Brant and Caldwell launched the expedition with the men they had. The exact composition of the force that left Unadilla is unclear. Sources generally agree that 152 Iroquois, principally Mohawk, were in the force, but that the Loyalists numbered between 200 and 300. Because of warnings received earlier that Brant was planning an attack, Bellinger had been sending out scouts in the direction of Unadilla to gather intelligence.

On September 16, Brant's company overwhelmed a scouting party of nine, killing a few and scattering the rest. One of the survivors was Adam Helmer, who ran 26 miles ahead of the advancing force to warn German Flatts. Bellinger sounded the call to arms of his regiment and sent an urgent request to Colonel Jacob Klock for the assistance of his regiment, while the settlers took refuge in the forts

Raid Begins

On the evening of September 16, Caldwell, Brant, and their men arrived at German Flatts not long after Helmer's warning, and began their attack the next morning. Because the settlers had taken refuge in the forts, there was no significant opportunity for the raiders to take prisoners or scalps.

They demonstrated before the forts, but lacked heavy weapons with which to properly assault them. They instead rampaged through the communities on both sides of the Mohawk, destroying 63 homes, a similar number of barns, three grist mills, and one saw mill. They drove off a large number of horses, cattle, and sheep, killing those they could not take with them.

The only buildings left standing were the forts, a barn, the church, and the homes of the minister and a few Loyalists. More than 700 people were made homeless by their destruction. Because of Helmer's warning, only three Americans were killed.

Captain Caldwell wrote that his men "would have in all probability killed most of the inhabitants of German Flatts had they not been apprised of our coming by one of the scouts getting in and warning of our approach, and perhaps got to their forts".

Aftermath

Klock's regiment did not arrive until after the raiders had left. The militia pursued the raiders, but were unable to catch up with them. Some friendly Oneidas and Tuscaroras, however, capitalized on Brant's absence from Unadilla to raid that town, freeing prisoners that Brant had taken while en route to German Flatts.

The Americans launched retaliatory raids in early October that destroyed Unadilla and Onaquaga. Brant and John Butler's son, Walter, organized a retaliatory expedition against Cherry Valley, which was the scene of a massacre in November. This action and others by Brant and Butler contributed to the decision by the Continental Congress to authorize a major Continental Army expedition into Iroquois territory. Commanded by Major General John Sullivan and Brigadier General James Clinton, the 1779 expedition systematically destroyed the villages of Iroquois tribes fighting for the British, but did little to stop the frontier war.

The German Flatts area in particular was the subject of repeated raids